PAST COMMODORES (*deceased/bold: current member)
| * | Hobart Dunbar | 1937 |
| * | Edgar Thomas | 1938 - 1940 |
| * | Ray Doyle | 1941 |
| * | Morrill Lay | 1942 - 1943 |
| * | Alfred Merrill | 1944 – 1945 |
| * | James Addison Jr | 1946 |
| * | Alan Ballantyne | 1947, 1953 |
| * | James Perrin | 1948 |
| * | Walter Livingston | 1949 |
| * | Maxwell Pierre | 1950 |
| * | Glen Smith | 1951 |
| * | Dan Gwyn | 1952 |
| * | J.L. Johnson | 1954 |
| * | Herbert White | 1955 |
| * | Harrison Ives | 1956 |
| * | Bill Anderson | 1957 |
| * | John Kommers | 1958 |
| * | Bob Julius | 1959 |
| * | Tom Adkins | 1960 |
| * | Dave Wilson | 1961 |
| * | Frank Nark | 1962, 1966-1967 |
| * | Bob Ullman | 1963 |
| * | Harry Archer | 1964 |
| * | Dan Rowand | 1965 |
| * | Ted Kohankie | 1968 |
| * | Peter Hughes | 1969 |
| * | John Bureau | 1970 |
| * | Charles Lober | 1971 |
| * | Glen Reinders | 1972 |
| * | Henry Ingersol | 1973 |
| * | Bryant Kistler | 1974 |
| * | Virgil Oliver | 1975 |
| * | Clarence Metzger | 1976 |
| David Hyder | 1977 | |
| * | Don Musselman | 1978 |
| * | Jerry Craft | 1979 |
| Tom Eagan | 1980 | |
| * | Jim Woodward | 1981 |
| * | Tim Birthisel | 1982 |
| * | Gene Harms | 1983 |
| Robert Hawker | 1984 | |
| * | Ronald Sattler | 1985 |
| * | Richard Watkins | 1986 |
| * | Sally Metzger | 1987 |
| Mike Bureau | 1988 | |
| * | Bill Dauer | 1989 |
| * | Ray Steely | 1990 |
| * | Dough Santchi | 1991 |
| * | Geoff Sickles | 1992 |
| Kelly McCarthy | 1993 | |
| Larry Graser | 1994 | |
| * | Dick Luedtke | 1995 |
| Don Durkin | 1996 | |
| Ed Plante | 1997 | |
| Debbi Grosskopf | 1998 | |
| Fred Lange | 2000 | |
| Dennis Whitmire | 2001 | |
| Peter Jacobsen | 2002 | |
| Wayne Eilers | 2003 | |
| Don Hoste | 2004 | |
| John Elden | 2005 | |
| Jim Williams | 2006 | |
| Marylin Metti | 2007, 2014 | |
| Jerry Abair | 2008, 2015, 2023 | |
| Dave Dicke | 2009 | |
| Dick Wagoner | 2010 | |
| Steve Thomas | 2011 | |
| Don Hoste | 2012 | |
| Don Fritz | 2013 | |
| Steve Wise | 2016 | |
| Dave Dicke | 2017 | |
| Rob Brunner | 2018 | |
| Willard Buttner | 2019 | |
| Jeremy Ballert | 2020 | |
| Jim Coyle | 2021 | |
| Phil LaCourse | 2022 | |
| Jerry Abair | 2023 | |
| Joel Imel | 2024 | |
| Marianne Corrao | 2025 | |
| Dave Brooks | 2026 | |